In general, raised garden beds are often more productive than in-ground beds. This is because the soil is not compacted, and they have better drainage. However, in colder climates, raised beds may freeze easier than inground plants. Whether it’s better to use a raised garden bed or not depends on a variety of factors. Factors including personal preferences, space limitations, and soil conditions.
Advantages Of Raised Garden Beds:
Better Drainage
Raised garden beds allow for better drainage, reducing the risk of waterlogged soil and root rot. In raised garden beds, the soil is added every growing season to allow for additional nutrients. This addition allows for the soil to remain loose and pliable. Pliable soil provides ideal growing conditions for rooting crops.
Improved Soil Quality
Because the soil in a raised garden bed is not compacted, it is often of higher quality and provides better growing conditions for plants. Compost, leaf mulch, grass clippings, and other organic matter may be added. However, raised garden beds may require more fertilization and added nutrients than inground gardening, due to the drainage. Additionally, the soil will need to be added to regularly to keep soil levels hi
Pest Control
Raised garden beds can help to reduce the populations of certain pests, such as slugs and snails. These type of pests have a hard time accessing a tall bed. Additionally, animal pests, such as moles and gophers can be prevented from getting in raised garden beds if a mesh bottom or rock base is added.
Better Accessibility
Raised garden beds can be easier to access for gardening, especially for those with mobility issues, as they are elevated from the ground. Although raised garden beds can be made to a variety of heights, 2ft to 3ft high is ideal for back support as it requires less bending. However, a taller raised garden bed will be more expensive to fill with quality soil.
Efficient Use of Space
Raised garden beds can be a great option for those with limited garden space, as they allow for more efficient use of space. For small backyard gardeners, or even balcony gardeners, a raised garden bed is ideal to allow for rich soil to grow crops like tomatoes or squash. Additionally, raised garden beds may be made to any shape to fit the gardeners needs.
Disadvantages Of Raised Garden Beds:
Raised Beds Can Be Expensive
Building a raised garden bed can be more expensive than traditional in-ground gardening, especially if the bed is to be built from materials such as stone or brick. Even large wooden raised garden beds can cost $100 or more depending on the wood. However, some raised garden beds may be made out of recycled wood materials but will need maintenance to upkeep them.
Maintenance and Repairs
Raised garden beds require more maintenance, as the soil needs to be regularly replenished and the beds need to be watered more frequently. Additionally, the materials of your raised garden beds may breakdown over time and need to be replaced. Wood rots, metal rusts, and rocks will begin to erode with constant watering.
In Ground Gardening
If using a raised garden bed seems daunting, or you are unable to put up the upfront costs of building a raised garden bed, then inground gardening is the way to go. The only drawback to inground gardening is the type of soil or soil quality you have to work with. Heavy clay soil, or sandy clay soil is difficult to garden in. Therefore, soil amendments may still need to be made for a prosperous garden.
An advantage to inground gardening is the ability for deep rooting plants to establish. Some rooting vegetables like to have a deeper space to grow into. Additionally, small fruiting shrubs or trees will need to be planted in deeper beds or inground to allow for their success.
Small Space Vs Large Space
If your garden is in a small space such as a balcony, or backyard, raised garden beds may offer the best option to grow in. Additionally, if gardening on a small scale or as a hobby, raised beds allow for a variety of different crops to grow.
If your garden space is large (1/4 acre or more) then inground gardening is more cost effective. In addition, if growing food crops on a large scale, inground gardening is easier to maintain due to the time saving tools that may be used to create the mounds and growing areas to plant in. If you are interested in how to layout your garden, visit our article on How to Layout a Garden Based on the Space Available.
In conclusion, raised garden beds can be a great option for those who want improved soil quality, better pest control, and better accessibility. However, it’s important to consider the cost and maintenance required before deciding. Ultimately, the best option will depend on individual preferences and the specific conditions of your garden.
Other Articles on Gardening Related to Garden Beds
Recent Posts
In general, to harvest your own seeds, you must choose mature, healthy plants, allow seeds to dry out, and remove the seeds when they are completely dry. However, this process will look different for...
A guide on how to store and organize seeds for your garden. Vegetables, flowers, herbs, or anything you are wanting to grow. How to Store Your Seeds Proper storage of garden seeds is essential...